In Chapel Hill, North Carolina, a research subject walked into a room and found a glass jar on a table. It held ten chocolate chip cookies, or it held two. Stephen Worchel and two colleagues ran 146 people through that setup for a paper published in 1975, and the cookies from the two-cookie jar came out better liked and more attractive. On taste, the ratings showed no significant difference.
Golf runs a version of that test with real money. Private clubs keep waiting lists and public courses hand out stamp cards, each trying to hold a golfer who could go elsewhere. In the Bronx, a company that runs casinos has held the lease on a public course since 2023.
The other half of the psychology came in 1990, when Frederick Reichheld and W. Earl Sasser Jr. told Harvard Business Review readers to stop losing the customers they already had. Put the jar and that ledger together and you get the modern retention offer, built to feel earned. Anyone receiving one should read it as a price change and do the sum before feeling flattered.
Private clubs got scarcer while the entry fee more than doubled
Golf Digest reported in May 2025 that 46 percent of US private clubs, counting residential golf communities, had waiting lists. The median initiation fee was $56,000. Before the pandemic, according to Ray Cronin of Club Benchmarking, that median was $25,000 and about a quarter of clubs had a list. Some waits ran past seven years.
Supply explains a good part of it. The same report counted 5,500 private clubs at the 1930s peak and 3,800 when it ran. Resignations slowed too: Cronin said attrition fell from 5 or 6 percent a year to 3 or 4, and at 3.5 percent a club takes 33 years to replace its membership.
Worchel's jars produced a finding that fits this better than the famous one does. Some participants watched the supply fall from ten cookies to two. They rated those cookies above the ones that had been scarce all along, and higher again when they were told demand had caused the drop instead of an accident. The authors guessed at bandwagon reasoning: "If everyone is trying it, it must be good."
A waiting list says that in writing. It's also honest, which is the awkward part, because nobody has to fake the demand. The list tells an applicant that other people want in, and it gives the member already inside a reason to keep paying dues for a spot that would be slow to win back.
A 1990 paper put a number on the customer who walks away
Harvard Business Review ran "Zero Defections: Quality Comes to Services" in its September-October 1990 issue. The summary said service companies were learning that "quality doesn't improve unless you measure it," and what Reichheld and Sasser wanted measured was customers leaving. The research firm Ipsos later quoted the claim that stuck: "by reducing customer defection by a mere 5%, companies can boost profits by 25% to 85%."
A company that believes that sentence will pay to keep people. A course has an extra reason to believe it, since a tee time nobody books can't be sold tomorrow.
Ipsos called the claim a myth in that same 2005 piece. A gain that large would need a very thin starting margin, it argued, and profit doesn't spread evenly across customers: it cited research finding that the most profitable fifth generate 150 to 300 percent of aggregate profit, while the least profitable fifth pull it down.
Some customers are worth paying to keep, and by the time an offer lands, the company has made up its mind about you. Any business with returning customers faces that decision, including the one holding that Bronx lease, with about nine years left on it.
A Bronx lease handed one company two sets of returning customers
The course at Ferry Point sits on public parkland, over a former landfill. New York City granted the Trump Organization a 20-year lease in 2012, with the term starting in 2015. In September 2023 Bally's took it over, for a sum that chairman Soo Kim wouldn't pin down beyond tens of millions. "Win or lose the casino bid, we will be in the New York City golf management business," he told the Bronx Times, through the end of the lease at least.
The bid won. New York's gaming commission approved a conditional license in December 2025 for a $4 billion Bally's resort at the site, with opening still about four years off, iGaming Business reported. Price was a sore point before any of that: the Bronx Times wrote in 2023 that the cost to play had drawn criticism, and Kim said the company would discuss it with the city.
One company now holds a golfer's tee time and, separately, a casino customer base with a loyalty program called Bally Rewards and an online brand called Bally Casino. The company's homepage doesn't say whether a round at Ferry Point earns anything in that program. Retention offers in both trades aim at somebody already on the books.
A casino's reload offer belongs in the same set as a course's returning-golfer rate, and it reads the same way, as a change in what the next purchase costs and a statement of who gets that price. On who gets it, the Bonus.com list of verified bonus codes for existing players says welcome codes stop at new customers, which rules out an account opened years ago or one on a sister brand sharing the same wallet.
Returning players get pointed toward reload promotions instead, and the page's authors say they test each code against the operator's live offer before it goes up.
The price only moves for someone who can buy at all. Real-money online casinos run in a handful of states, for players 21 and over, and New York isn't one of them, so a golfer standing at Ferry Point has no such market to enter. Where they're live, a reload is a deposit match with conditions attached, and a session can lose the whole balance, bonus or no bonus.
Arlington's $149.99 pass gives back 15 percent and one round
Public golf has no list to shorten. Its tee sheets are open to anyone, so its operators buy loyalty directly. KemperSports launched Frequent Fairways in April 2025 across Chicagoland, the Mid-Atlantic and the Northeast. Each qualifying round earns a stamp on an app, and the stamps reveal rewards, among them Titleist Pro V1 balls and a pair of FootJoy shoes.
Patrick Koenig's October guide to Chicago public golf makes a good check on that card. Six of the nine Chicagoland courses on Kemper's list appear in it, Harborside and Cantigny among them. So do Ravisloe and Cog Hill, which aren't on the card, and that's what a stamp is up against: the round you'd have played elsewhere. Koenig never mentions the program.
His Harborside entry does name Bally's Golf Links (the Ferry Point course since January 2024) among the links-style courses built on landfills, and he's talking about the ground under them, nothing else.
Arlington, Texas, makes the sum easier. The city's 2026 Frequent Players Club costs $149.99, or $189.99 with a GHIN membership, across four public courses. It takes 15 percent off the green fee and cart rental from Monday through Thursday and after noon on Friday, Saturday or Sunday. Divide the price by 0.15 and you get about $1,000 of eligible fees before the discount alone covers the card.
The pass also includes one complimentary round with half a cart. At a made-up $50 for green fee and cart, that round takes $50 off the bill and each discounted round saves $7.50, so the base pass needs 14 more rounds to break even. At that rate, someone who plays six times a year pays more per round for having joined.
Kemper's stamps are harder to price. The launch release doesn't say how many rounds a pair of shoes takes, and a reward with no published rate can't be set against anything.
Offers sent to a short list are the hardest ones to check
Worchel's paper builds on the commodity theory Brock published in 1968, and Brock had a specific idea about messages: the fewer people with access to one, the more persuasive it would be. The 1975 authors noted that earlier work on scarce communications hadn't upheld the prediction, so treat it as a suspicion. Golf and casinos both act as if it's true anyway.
A private club's rate for members tends to arrive in a newsletter that only members get. On the casino side, the promo-code page cited above says operators typically post existing-player codes in a promotions tab or send them by email without advertising them publicly.
The trouble with a private price is the missing comparison. Nobody on a short list can see what the person off it pays, or what the golfer in the next cart was sent. Arlington's eight-day advance booking is the cleaner sort of perk, because the city printed it in a news release for anyone to read.
A club's newsletter stops at the last name on its members' file. No admissions committee sits in front of Bonus.com on Facebook, which is as far as this comparison goes.
Naples clubs found out how far a waiting list can push a price
Scarcity has a limit, and it can break fast. Jason Becker, who cofounded a firm that evaluates residential golf communities, said in Golf Digest's report on club waiting lists that only five of the 90 clubs in Naples, Florida, had memberships available a year earlier, and that 17 did by May 2025. "Clubs got too aggressive on the initiation fees, and consumers said, 'We're not going to pay it,'" he said.
The cookie study saw a small version of this. People who watched a jar go from two cookies to ten rated them below people who'd seen ten all along. A perk that stops being scarce can end up worth less in a member's eyes than one that was never scarce, if cookies are any guide.
They may not be. The first experiment tested 146 women from one psychology course, and Ipsos disputed the 1990 profit claim. Neither paper can tell a golfer what a given offer is worth to them.
The sum can. Take last season's rounds and work out what each one cost you, green fee and cart. Then run the same rounds with the offer applied and its price added in, whether that's Arlington's $149.99 or whatever rate Ferry Point ends up charging. A reload goes through the same test, with its deposit and conditions on the cost side. If the second figure comes out higher, turn the offer down, flattered or not.